The Dyker Heights Christmas lights start inside a plant nursery in Bensonhurst. A 2021 ABC7 report found that James Bonavita's crew at B&R Christmas Decorators began its season in that nursery. The work started in August, when customers, many of them repeat clients, began booking and buying, months before anything lit up on 84th Street. "Everyone wants their lights done at one time so it's very stressful," Bonavita told ABC7.
The blocks between 83rd and 86th Streets, from 10th to 13th Avenues, look like the work of competing neighbors. A good share of what fills them comes from a seasonal Brooklyn trade. It has its own crews, its own territories and its own calendar, and a few households still put up their displays by hand alongside it. If you live in Dyker Heights or Bay Ridge, the season that crowds your sidewalk in December starts long before the first tour bus shows up.
Two Companies Once Handled Most of the Houses
In December 2019, Brooklyn Paper reported that two private companies had hung most of that season's displays. Crews from B&R and its main competitor, DiMeglio Decorators, had decorated about 85 percent of the neighborhood's houses since early November that year. B&R alone served more than 100 Dyker Heights houses in the 2019 season.
The two firms had split the area informally. "[They're] more Bay Ridge and I'm more Dyker Heights. We don't step on each other's toes," Bonavita told Brooklyn Paper. B&R's specialty was motion. Bonavita described animated figures and "one-of-a-kind ribbon imported from Italy."
The 2019 numbers explain why a pro-installed house looks the way it does. Bonavita said each house took three to five days, and that B&R would not take a job for less than $1,000. Homeowners bought the lights and ornaments themselves and reused them year after year. That arrangement lets a display grow a little each season, because the decorations stay with the house and only the labor is hired. ABC7's 2021 visit put a medium-size home at six to eight hours of work for a crew of 12, so the multi-day jobs from 2019 were most likely the biggest displays on the blocks.
Some people have called hiring a decorator cheating. Nando DiMeglio answered that in 2019 with a comparison anyone who owns an old Brooklyn house will recognize. "It's like if you want something on your car fixed or if you want to paint your wall, you hire someone who really knows how," he told Brooklyn Paper. "It's too much work for the homeowners to do it all themselves most of the time."
A Trade That Started With One Favor
Bonavita grew up in Bensonhurst. He told Brooklyn Paper in 2019 that he started 27 years earlier, after his father mentioned that some beginner decorators in Dyker Heights needed help. "I went and I showed them exactly what to do," he said. "As I was working, people were passing by in their cars and saying, 'You do lights?'"
B&R still presents itself as a working Brooklyn business. The company's site lists James Bonavita as CEO and describes a full-season service of design, installation, in-season maintenance and post-season removal. It also says his nephew, Domonic Bonavita, has been learning the trade. In a business that runs on repeat clients who book in August, that kind of family continuity counts for a lot.
The Newest Crew Arrived in 2022
The trade has added at least one company in recent years. Aleksandr Slatvitskii and Aleksei Sinenkov, who had run a similar business before coming to Brooklyn, registered Shinecraft as an LLC in October 2022 and decorated their first homes that winter, Brooklyn Paper reported in December 2024. In its second full season, 2024, Shinecraft was working on nearly 100 homes. That 2024 count is close to the 100-plus houses B&R reported in 2019 after nearly three decades of work. Shinecraft's installations that season started in early November and were expected to wrap up by mid-December. B&R's crews had also been at work since early November in 2019, so two firms more than 25 years apart in age start on the same weeks of the year.
The Workshop Behind Toyland
Some of the neighborhood's best-known pieces came out of a Brooklyn workshop. Lou Nasti founded Mechanical Displays in 1969 after early work on Macy's Santaland. His business grew into an 80,000-square-foot operation in Queens before he downsized and moved it to Flatbush, according to a 2025 VMSD obituary that drew on The New York Times. His clients over the years included B. Altman and FAO Schwarz.
In Dyker Heights, Nasti was the man behind "Toyland," the display at the Polizzotto house on 84th Street between 11th and 12th Avenues. Brooklyn Paper described its 30-foot nutcrackers and its moving Santa, dancers and horses. "Forty years I've been going that house," Nasti told the paper in 2020, the year Toyland stayed dark. The family divided the decorations among homes in New Jersey and Nassau County. VMSD put his run at the house at more than 30 years. Nasti died on Feb. 28, 2025, at 79, so this is the second Dyker Lights season without him.
The Households That Still Do the Work
Across 84th Street from where Toyland stood is the house where the tradition started. Lucy Spata began decorating her home in the 1980s in memory of her mother, who loved Christmas. She told Brooklyn Paper in 2023 that her children know the house should stay decorated for years to come, a remark the paper repeated in its 2025 guide.
On 83rd Street, the "Believe" house at 1023 83rd St. shows the do-it-yourself version of the season. Frank Mangano bought the giant rooftop sign while Christmas shopping in 2020, and visitors now line up for photos on a red carpet at the foot of his stairs, Brooklyn Paper reported in December 2024. His 2024 display had an estimated 100 giant bulbs and more than 50,000 lights. He and a friend modified each of the big bulbs, pulling out the small LED and fitting a bulb socket in its place.
Mangano's schedule matches the pros. He and his friend Francesco Buscema start in early November and take about two to three weeks to set everything up. "It's hard to estimate an exact dollar amount, but it would be tens of thousands of dollars through the years I have spent on decorations and lights," he told Brooklyn Paper. That figure covers several seasons of buying for one house. It lines up with the paper's 2025 observation that some homeowners invest tens of thousands of dollars each season, often with professional decorators handling the design, installation and maintenance.
The Season on the Calendar From Here
With installs historically running from early November to mid-December, most homes light up in late November or early December. Displays usually stay up through Christmas and sometimes into early January, according to Brooklyn Paper's December 2025 guide. The same guide named mid-December weekends between 5 and 9 p.m. as the busiest stretch and said weeknights are usually less crowded.
Organized visitors are on the calendar already. One private tour company lists Nov. 27, the day after Thanksgiving, as its first 2026 date. It sells bus seats at $75 for a roughly four-hour trip that leaves from near the New York Public Library at Fifth Avenue and 41st Street. For neighbors, the transit routes matter more. Brooklyn Paper points visitors to the R train at 86th Street or the D train at 79th Street, then a 10- to 15-minute walk.
The commerce on the blocks is homegrown too. During the 2025 season, homeowners set up their own stands selling hot chocolate, snacks and Dyker Heights Christmas Lights T-shirts. Community Board 10 District Manager Josephine Beckmann has worked with the Mayor's Office to bring in extra trash bins and traffic control during the season. If you live a few blocks off the main stretch, the weeks right after Thanksgiving are a good time to walk the displays before the mid-December weekend crowds.
Houses on 83rd through 86th Streets draw visitors from around the world every December. John O'Kane has worked Brooklyn and Queens blocks for more than 35 years and knows how that kind of local character plays into what a home is worth. If you own in Dyker Heights or Bay Ridge, or anywhere on our Brooklyn neighborhood page, and want a clear read on your property, call John for a consultation.